Monday, February 28, 2011

Starlighter by Bryan Davis


Once long ago there was a land, this land was inhabited by dragons. One day a mighty dragon realized that their race was slowly dieing. He learned that he needed to find a new land or slaves to mine for a very important gas, so he, and the rest of his race could live. He searched and found a land that had humans, he took a few of them back to his world to work for him.
The story of Starlighter is about the people taken by the dragon and the people left behind.

I was disappointed with this book. After reading over 10 of Bryan Davis’s other books this one just seemed to blend in with the rest. The land had the same feel as any of his other series, even though it was different. The only way I can describe the world is Star Wars crossed with Rome.

I think I am finally learning why I don't like Bryan Davis’s books, the characters. They are either flat or perfect. The best fighter in he world, the honorable gentleman, the kind hearted girl that studies everything dutifully. Now I will admit that I am not perfect, so reading about these perfect people bore me. I mean even the liar never lied. I know everything will turn out right in the end so why do I care what happens to them now? It will all be okay. Since the characters are already near perfect not a lot of character development is open, which I feel hurt the plot.
With dragons, there is a point were everyone will say, they are too human. I found it in this book. Please don't get me wrong I love smart dragons just this is overboard for me. The dragon made a debate, the dragon bowed, the dragon is kind hearted. Ummmmm okey... Great! More people, just they are in dragon bodies.

The plot is unique, just like all of Bryan Davis’s plots. The finger, the romance, portals, mind bending puzzles, odd creatures, ‘twas very Davis style.

Now this book is good if you just want something entertaining to read, but I won’t go out and buy it.

C+

Comments (8)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Good, honest review. :) You are reading Masters & Slayers next, right? I wonder what you'll think of that one. I'm in the middle of reading it myself, and in my opinion it is far better than Starlighter.
Oh, weird. I just noticed that the cover has a "the" on it. So what, it's called "The Starlighter" now? lol! They must've just changed it. My copy doesn't have that. I wonder if they'll change Warrior and Diviner too...

Anyway, great review. :)
The reason why all his characters don't sin is because Bryan Davis believes that true Christians can't sin. He said it on his forums a while back...
I must say I very much disagree. I honestly found these characters to be very strong. Warrior shows their weaknesses and is FAR better than Starlighter. I do admit there were some weaknesses in writing the characters in this book....but Arxad was wonderful and any issues with character are well fixed in Warrior. Masters and Slayers as well.

I'm a long time Davis fan and found this book to be very well done. For an opposing review see mine from a while ago: http://whisperedroars.blogspot.com/2010/03/starli...

As for perfect heroes...I find that inspiring not boring ::shrugs:: There is typically a tension between doing the right thing or failing and I LOVE reading about this tension and then seeing people come out victoriously. However, if you want REAL struggle....read Warrior. Koren has some very intense situations and, perhaps, is not always perfect depending on your point of view of perfection.

::shrugs::
Michelle Archer's avatar

Michelle Archer · 734 weeks ago

Thanks guys!

Cson I never noticed that... I will have to look into it.

Guywithbook (Beorn)- I understand that Davis believes that. But it doesn't mean I have to believe it or give Davis slack. I don't like that fact about his characters.

Nathan- I hope Warrior is better. I am not a huge Davis fan so your review to balance mine is great. Thank you.

Also all- for some reason I have to moderate these comments (even though I have told the computer to let all comments go through without moderating) and then to email me when people post. It isn't working right, it doesn't allow you to post without moderation and it isn't emailing me.
Since the comment section is glitching and not showing _ comments I couldn't tell you posted. Sorry about that and I'll try to do better now that I know of it.
@Guywithbook. He does have a better reason why his characters are usually like that. I interviewed him on my blog a few weeks ago and asked him about it. http://bit.ly/eXecrf
These are the first blatantly honest reviews I have read of Starlighter and of Masters and Slayers. I entirely agree with it too. Thanks for posting. :]

--A.W.
Not to buy, good to read, good to know. :-)

Post a new comment

Comments by